Babies-Kids and Kittens-The Hidden Danger-Dr. Don DeForge-Silver Sands Veterinary Center
Dr. Don DeForge Silver Sands Veterinary Center 21May2016
Babies, Kids, and Kittens
The Hidden Danger
Babies-Kids and Kittens-Cats--- A Hidden Danger
Parents are always concerned about injury to their baby or toddler. Even as toddlers develop into small children parents protect and monitor every move that the young person makes. The first step; the first "real" food; the first ice cream cone; the first activity at gymnastics; the first swim; and even the first swing of a baseball bat-----parents are there watching; helping; and protecting!
In a past blog, I discussed the Zoonosis of Toxocariasis-an intestinal parasite of puppies, kittens, and adult companion animals that can parasitize children and adults.
The AVMA-The American Veterinary Medical Association recommends that veterinarians take a proactive role in the prevention of zoonotic diseases. Today, this blog will review the most up to date information from Dr. William Hardy at the National Veterinary Lab concerning the zoonosis of Bartonella infection. Adults and children can be infected by cats or kittens that carry Bartonella.
From the National Veterinary Lab:
Bartonella are Gram-negative, fastidious bacteria (approximately 20 species known to date) that are
widespread in nature infecting many animal species from wild rodents, ruminants, pet animals, to humans.
They are transmitted by arthropod vectors including fleas, ticks, biting flies, and lice from animal-to animal
(intraspecies) and species to species (interspecies). Direct animal-to-animal transmission, without
vectors, probably occurs rarely and is exemplified by the transmission from cats to humans via scratches,
bites, and fur contact.
Kids are very active and at times uncontrollable. Kittens are the same. You place a kitten and a youngster together and the chance of a cat scratch during play is very high. Energetic kids and kittens/cats can lead to reckless injury and potential transmission of the Bartonella bacterial disease from cat-kitten to child-adult.
From the National Veterinary Lab Newsletter-Evelyn E. Zuckerman, Editon:
"It is still perplexing that veterinarians routinely test for feline retroviruses, FeLV and FIV, with an incidence of only 3.1% combined, where there is no therapy for either virus, and no zoonotic potential, but do not routinely test for Bartonella. Few veterinarians recommend routine testing for
Bartonella, where the occurrence is about 35%, they cause far more disease, there is an
excellent sterilizing response to antibiotic therapy, and where there is a significant zoonotic threat.
NEWSLETTER
Let’s Get Serious About Bartonella!
©
Evelyn E. Zuckerman, Editor Spring 2013 Vol. 12, Number 2
In This Issue:
Accumulating evidence demonstrates that
Bartonella is endemic in cats and the zoonosis is
being recognized as a “silent epidemic” in humans.
In addition, the concern in the veterinary profession
is lacking and the knowledge of the Bartonella
diseases in the medical community could be better.
Veterinarians:
Responsibility: Cats are the major reservoir host for
at least 6 Bartonella species and feline Bartonella
cause inflammatory diseases in experimentally
inoculated and in pet cats.Despite the ample
published evidence for the past 20 years supporting
these facts, there are web sites, chat rooms, and on
line blogs that still present misleading and incorrect
information.
Fleas transmit Bartonella among cats
and spring brings increased flea exposure. Thus
veterinarians must become familiar with the
published facts and “get serious about Bartonella”
for their patient’s and for their client’s health.
It is still perplexing that veterinarians routinely test
for feline retroviruses, FeLV and FIV, with an
incidence of only 3.1% combined, where there is no
therapy for either virus, and no zoonotic potential,
but do not routinely test for Bartonella.
Few veterinarians recommend routine testing for
Bartonella, where the occurrence is about 35%
(Table 1), they cause far more disease, there is an
excellent sterilizing response to antibiotic therapy,
13
and where there is a significant zoonotic threat.
Table 1
Common Pathogens* in 7,484 Healthy Cats
Pathogen No.
Tested
No.
Infected
%
Infected
FeLV IFA 7,484 84 1.1%
FIV WB 7,484 147 2.0%
Bartonella WB 7,484 2,604 35%
*All tests performed by National Veterinary Laboratory
Veterinarians who do not discuss Bartonella with
their clients expose themselves to legal liability
when one of their clients develops a Bartonella
disease from one of their cats. Many
veterinarians test for Bartonella when they are
trying to determine the cause of an
inflammatory disease, but will not routinely
test healthy cats along with the routine
retroviral tests and fecal examinations. As will
be discussed later, most zoonotic spread of
Bartonella to cat owners occurs from
HEALTHY kittens under 1 year of age, the
animals where early tests and vaccinations are
routine.
Fleas and Ticks:
Cat fleas are responsible for the great majority
of transmission of Bartonella among cats.
Thus, flea control is essential for interrupting
the transmission. To a lesser extent, ticks can
also occasionally transmit Bartonella between
cats but they are the more important vector for
transmitting Bartonella to dogs. Dogs are
much less a reservoir host for Bartonella than
are cats.
Cat Flea Dog ticks
Cats and dogs that have been strays, feral,
originated from shelters or rescue groups, and
those living in multiple cat or dog households,
(Table 2) are more likely to have had flea
infestation and thus more likely to be infected.
Table 2
Healthy Cat Risk Factors for Bartonella Infection
Risk Factor No
Tested
%
Infected
Risk
Factor
(X)
None 840 20% X
CSD Household 1,057 57% 2.9X
Strays 16,499 41% 2.1X
Shelter 10,191 33% 1.7X
Fleas: History of 9,072 48% 2.4X
Current 3,510 45% 2.3X
Multi Cat Hh 26,973 41% 2.1X
Exposed to
Bartonella + Cat 7,229 54% 2.7X
Totals: 74,531 42% 2.1X
Hh= household Many cats had multiple risk
factors. 12 years of tests to 11-4-2011
These animals certainly warrant discussion
with their owners regarding the feline disease
potential and the zoonotic dangers.
Feral Cats:
As the pet populations increased after WWII, so
did the stray dog and cat populations. This topic
has been expertly researched and described by
my long time scuba diving friend, Jim Sterba, in
his excellent new book Nature Wars, published
by Crown, New York about how wildlife
comebacks turned backyards into battlegrounds
(I highly recommend this book for veterinarians
and animal lovers) www.jimsterba.com.
Jim Sterba (left) & Dr. Hardy, Fiji 1983
Jim spent years researching all aspects of the
closeness of contemporary people to wildlife
and the joys and problems this has fostered. In
the chapter entitled “Feral Felines,” Sterba
chronicles the evolution of pet cats that evolved
to shelter cats then to a feral lifestyle. This was
due to the high percentage of shelter cats that
had been euthanized over the years because of
the low percentage of shelter adoptions. As we
all know, the controversial policy of TNR- trapneuter-return
has grown where the intent to
lower the population of feral cats has met with
Feeding feral cat colony TNR poster
mixed results. Sterilized feral cats still pose
dangers by carrying diseases, killing large
numbers of wildlife, and their “colonies” can act
as a dumping ground for fertile unwanted pet
cats. Of course feral cats carry one of the
highest Bartonella infection rates of all cats and
they have been a source for numerous zoonotic
transmissions to good hearted people who have
tried to care for them. Many “shelter cats”
originate as feral cats and adoptions pose a risk
to the household members.
In an urban feral cat study, conceived by Dr.
Douglas Wyler, owner of the Whitestone Veterinary
Care in Whitestone, NY, a suburb of New York
City, we found that feral cats more frequently carry
infectious microorganisms when compared to
owned cats. Both Bartonella and FIV prevalence is
elevated in these feral colonies sampled, Table 3.
Table 3
Common Pathogens* in 102 Feral Cats
Pathogen No.
Infected
% Infected
FeLV IFA 1 0.9%
FIV WB 9 9%
Bartonella WB 50 49%
*All tests performed by National Veterinary Laboratory
The Bartonella infection incidence in healthy
owned cats from this practice is only 18%. Since a
large number of pet cats originate as adoptions of
strays or feral cats, veterinarians should “get serious
about Bartonella” and the public health dangers for
their clients and themselves.
Physicians:
Many physicians are not thoroughly knowledgeable
or are dismissive of the Bartonella diseases in their
patients. Physicians must also “get serious about
Bartonella” as it has been suggested that Bartonella
is a silent epidemic. Bartonella is a stealth or
chronic pathogen which makes detection and
correlation with the clinical signs difficult for
physicians. In addition, the zoonotic event, a cat
scratch, bite, or tick bite, may have occurred weeks
or months before the clinical signs begin. This long
temporal interval can often negate consideration of
this causative event by the patient or the physician.
There has been continuing controversy that
Bartonella do not fulfill Koch’s Postulates as the
cause of cat disease despite numerous publications
to the contrary, some 17 years ago.14-15 It has been
known for some time that there are frontal and
stealth pathogens.16 We wrote in our Summer 2005
NLV Newsletter, available at www.natvetlab.com,
that the major difference is frontal pathogens are
aggressive rapidly acting, whereas stealth pathogens
are slow chronic mild inducers of disease, Table 4.
Table 4
Frontal vs. Stealth Pathogenic Bacteria
Frontal- (Aggressive): Stealth- (Slow-Mild):
Incubation period: Short Long/ indeterminate
Clinical sign: Acute Chronic
Innate immune system: Engages Engages
Multiplication: Rapid Slow
Carrier state: Uncommon Common- shedding
Sterilizing immunity: Induces Rarely induces
Adaptive immunity: Engages Avoids or manipulates
Bacterial Examples:
Yersinia & Vibrio Bartonella & Helicobacter
Adapted from: Merrell, D.S. & Falkow, S., Ref 16.
In fact, a recent paper has suggested adding another
criterion, the “postulate of comparative infectious
disease causation” to the four venerable Koch’s
Postulates for determination of a causative etiology
of diseases by stealth pathogens.
17
In this regard,
the proposed new postulate is not needed for
Bartonella diseases of cats since there are ample
publications that have fulfilled the original Koch’s
Postulates for the Bartonella etiology of
inflammatory diseases.1-12
We will again present our abstract from the 7th
International Bartonella Meeting which
summarizes the misconceptions that
veterinarians and physicians have about
Bartonella. We do this so that both professions
can “take Bartonella seriously” in the spring
when fleas transit Bartonella to cats and cats
then transmit Bartonella to people.
All Bartonella Diseases are not “Cat Scratch
Disease”: Misconceptions about
Bartonellosis. 7
th Intern. Conf. on Bartonella
as Animal and Human Pathogens, 2012.
Common misconceptions about cat scratch
disease (CSD) are that: 1) fleas or flea dirt
must be present on cats in order to transmit the
bacteria to people, 2) there is no need to test or
treat healthy cats, 3) CSD is the only
Bartonella disease, and 4) CSD is a benign
self-limiting disease. With the assistance of
many of our veterinary clients, we were able to
interview more than 500 people who had
reported developing a Bartonella disease.
These individuals had their cats tested for
Bartonella at our laboratory after they were
diagnosed with a Bartonella disease. We
identified 283 people with a Bartonella disease
who were diagnosed with the infection. 61%
had developed classic CSD with fever,
lymphadenopathy, malaise, and a papule. 23%
developed CSD and sequelae consisting of
chorioretinitis, cognitive dysfunction,
psychoses, neurologic disorders, endocarditis,
and hepatosplenomegaly. Finally, 16%
developed only bartonellosis or sequelae with
no classic CSD prodrome signs. 77% of the
cases occurred in adults. 50% of the people
developed chronic myalgia and arthralgia and
30% developed mental alterations including
depression, cognitive dysfunctions, “brain
fog,” and panic disorders.
Classic CSD Prodrome “Brain fog” metaphor
Cats that transmitted Bartonella were
identified in 201 of the 283 cases or 71%. 97%
of the cats were serologically WB positive for
Bartonella infection, 65% were healthy, 49%
were kittens under one year of age and 83%
had no fleas or flea dirt on them at the time
they transmitted the bacterium to people. The
routes of infection were identified in 69% of
the cases. Of these, 75% by scratches, 13% by
bites or scratches, 5% by administering oral
medication, and 31% by unknown routes.
Thus healthy kittens, less than one year of
age obtained as strays, from shelters or as
feral cats, are the most likely to transmit
Bartonella to people. The AAFP, CDC, and
many academic websites do not recommend
testing of healthy cats for Bartonella.
Excluding the 40 veterinary professionals who
had developed Bartonella diseases in this study
94% of the patients had NOT been informed of
the zoonotic danger of feline Bartonella by
their veterinarians before their illness occurred.
In addition, 70% of the patients had difficulty
in obtaining a diagnosis or had to urge or insist
that their physician consider Bartonella as a
possible cause of their illness.
References:
1. Greene, CE, et al. Bartonella henselae infection in
cats: evaluation during primary infection, treatment,
and rechallenge infection. J Clin Microbiol 34:1682-
1685, 1996.
2. Guptill L, et al. Experimental infection of young
specific pathogen-free cats with Bartonella henselae.
J Infect Dis 176:206-216, 1997.
3. Kordick DL et al.: Clinical and pathologic
evaluation of chronic Bartonella henselae or
Bartonella clarridgeiae infection in cats. J Clin
Microbiol 37:1536-1547, 1999.
4. O’Reilly, KL et al.: Acute clinical disease in cats
following infection with a pathogenic strain of
Bartonella henselae (LSU16). Infect Immun 67:3066-
3072, 1999.
5. Mikolajczyk MG, O'Reilly KL: Clinical disease in
kittens inoculated with a pathogenic strain of
Bartonella henselae. Am J Vet Res 61:375-379, 2000.
6. O’Reilly KL et al.: Passive antibody to Bartonella
henselae protects against clinical disease following
homologous challenge but does not prevent bacteremia
in cats. Infect Immun 69:1880-1882, 2001.
7. Glaus, T., et al. Seroprevalence of Bartonella
henselae infection and correlation with disease status
in cats in Switzerland. J Clin Microbiol 35:2883, 1997.
8. Hardy, WD, Jr., Zuckerman, E, Corbishley, J.
Seroprevalence of Bartonella-infection in healthy and
diseased cats in the United States and Caribbean:
Evidence for Bartonella-induced diseases in cats.
International Conference of the American Society for
Rickettsiology, Big Sky, MT, August 17-22, 2001.
9. Chomel, BB, et al. Fatal case of endocarditis
associated with Bartonella henselae type I infection in
a domestic cat. Clin Microbiol 41:5337-5339, 2003.
10. Ketring, KL, Zuckerman, EE & Hardy, WD, Jr.
Bartonella: A new etiological agent of feline ocular
diseases. JAAHA, 40: 6-12, 2004.
11. Varanat, M, et al. Recurrent osteomyelitis in a cat
due to infection with Bartonella vinsonii subsp.
berkhoffii genotype II. J Vet Intern Med 23:1273-
1277, 2009.
12. Sykes, JE, et al. Association between Bartonella
infection and disease in pet cats. Abstract A1. Intern
Conf on Bartonella as Medical & Veterinary
Pathogens, Chester, UK, June 2009.
13. Hardy, W.D., JR., Zuckerman, E.E., Corbishley,
J. et al. Successful therapy of Bartonella henselae
bacteremic healthy pet cats. Annual Meeting, Infect.
Dis. Soc. of America, New Orleans, Sept., 1996.
14. Koch R.: Uber bakteriologische Forschung
Verhandlung des X Internationalen Medichinischen
Congresses, Berlin, 1890, 1, 35. August Hirschwald,
Berlin. (In German.) Xth International Congress of
Medicine, Berlin, 1981.
15. Jacomo, V., Kelly, P.J. Raoult, D. Natural history
of Bartonella infections (an exception to Koch’s
Postulate). Cl. Diag. Lab. Immunol. 9: 8-18, 2002.
16. Merrell, D.S. and Falkow, S. Frontal and stealth
attack strategies in microbial pathogenesis. Nature
430: 250-256, 2004.
17. Breitschwerdt, E.B., et al. Koch’s postulates and
the pathogenesis of comparative infectious disease
causation associated with Bartonella species. J Comp
Path http:dx.doi.org/10,1016/j.jcpa.2012.12.003 1-11.
Bartonella references can be obtained at:
www.nlm.nih.gov/ or natvetlab.com
©National Veterinary Laboratory, Inc., 2013
National Veterinary Lab Recommendation concerning Bartonella Infection:
1. Discuss the public health aspects of
Bartonella infected cats with your clients.
2. Recommend testing all cats in the
household.
3. Treat only those cats that are test positive.
4. Recommend therapy evaluation tests 6
months after the end of therapy.
5. If the owner refuses to test all cats in the
household, note that refusal and date in your
records.
6. Implement stringent flea control for the
household.
Policy of Silver Sands Veterinary Center-DH DeForge, VMD: Bartonella a Serious Zoononsis-Public Health Protocol--
Any client, family member, or friend scratched or bitten by a Bartonella infected cat/kitten should be cautioned to call their physician/pediatrician immediately. Refer the Pediatrician-Physician to the National Veterinary Laboratory Website. Give a copy of the Positive Feline Bartonella Test to your physician-pediatrician. The Bartonella infected cat is treated according to National Veterinary Lab Guidelines with Azithromycin. All cats in the household of the infected cat must be tested for Bartonella disease.
16th Anniversary of National Veterinary Lab Bartonella Screening Test
NEWSLETTER
The FeBart®
(Bartonella) Test is Sweet 16©
Evelyn E. Zuckerman, Editor Fall 2015 Vol. 14, Number 4
In This Issue:
On November 4, 2015
I was again trying to
decide on a subject for our 56th quarterly NVL
Newsletter when it finally dawned on me that this
very date was the 16th anniversary of our
introduction of the FeBart® Test, a western blot
(WB) serological test, for detection of Bartonella.
Yes, 16 years ago the National Veterinary
Laboratory was the first diagnostic laboratory to
offer a routine Bartonella screening test. During
these stimulating 16 years we have tested
338,393 cats and 9,381 dogs for Bartonella. In
this Newsletter, I will recall our experiences, both
good and bad, during these years. The most
rewarding aspect has been the interactions with
the thousands of veterinarians who utilized our
services and taught us about the clinical aspects
of Bartonella.
William D. Hardy, Jr. V.M.D.
Director and Owner
National Veterinary Laboratory, Inc.
Introduction:
We began to study the zoonotic pathogen
Bartonella shortly after its discovery in 1990.1
In
1995, after 5 years of research of comparison of
culture isolation with serology, our data showed
that the most accurate and reproducible test for
detection of Bartonella infection in cats was the
serologic detection of antibodies to the bacteria
using the western blot (WB). The WB is the
most specific (accurate) and sensitive serologic
assay for the detection of many microorganisms.
It is used in human medicine to confirm ELISA
positive HIV screening tests, Lyme positive
serology and several others. In veterinary
medicine it is also used to confirm FIV ELISA
positive serology. Detection of antibodies to an
etiological agent is an amplification system when
antibodies coexist with etiological agents as they
do in FIV and Bartonella infections in cats.
The National Veterinary Laboratory Inc. (NVL)
is the oldest private veterinary diagnostic
laboratory in the country. Dr. Hardy developed
the first diagnostic test for FeLV infection in
1972 while at the Memorial Sloan Kettering
Cancer Center, the IFA test for detection of FeLV
antigens in cat leukocytes and platelets (FeLeuk®
Test). He and his colleagues used the test to
discover that FeLV is spread contagiously
between cats.
This discovery changed the paradigm that
retroviruses were no longer thought to only be
transmitted genetically (vertically). NVL was
then established in 1973 to provide this
inexpensive, practical, and accurate test for
screening cats for this virus and led to
programs that lowered the transmission among
cats. The FeLeuk® Test remains the “Gold
Standard” confirmatory screening test for
detection of FeLV infection.
Bartonella: During the early HIV
retrovirus epidemic in the early 1990s,
physicians in the many medical centers began
to observe life-threatening cases of Bartonella
infections in HIV infected patients. Since we
had worked with feline retroviruses, and since
Bartonella was known to be transmitted by
cats, we began to study the occurrence of
Bartonella in cats and developed IFA, ELISA
and WB tests for Bartonella. It took more than
5 years, and tests of more than 5,000 cats, to
develop and
verify the
accuracy of
our
diagnostic
Bartonella
tests. After
thousands
of
comparative
IFA, ELISA and western blot tests we chose
the much more specific western blot (WB) as a
screening test because, in our laboratory, it is
more sensitive and more reproducible than the
other Bartonella serological methods.
FeBart® Bartonella Western Blot Test
Happy Sweet 16th Birthday!
The WB test can differentiate Bartonellainfected
cats from cats that may react nonspecifically,
or have cross-reactive antibodies,
in IFA or ELISA tests, to Chlamydia or other
microorganisms. The FeBart® test detects
antibodies to as many as 14 Bartonella
proteins and the test correlates well with
infection or lack of infection in cats.
With
more that 4,000 Bartonella publications at present,
there is ample evidence that Bartonella infection
(updated paradigm) is not always self-limiting in
people, that there are Bartonella tests available, and
that Bartonella do cause inflammatory diseases in
cats.
In fact, two of the academics who
made many of the early negative statements
regarding testing cats later developed their own
commercial Bartonella tests.
Veterinarians and Physicians Must
Consider Bartonella as Important
Pathogens- Updated Paradigm:
After interacting with thousands of veterinarians
during the past 16 years I still feel that many in
our profession do not fully appreciate the
importance of Bartonella in cats or in people.
Likewise, after interviewing more that 500
people infected with Bartonella, it is clear that a
substantial proportion of physicians do not know
much about Bartonella or are dismissive of their
clinical importance. Our findings, presented at
the 7
th
International Conference on Bartonella in
2012, support these conclusions.
All Bartonella Diseases are not “Cat Scratch
Disease:” Misconceptions about Bartonellosis.
WD Hardy and EE Zuckerman, 7
th
International Conference on Bartonella as
Animal and Human Pathogens, Raleigh, NC,
April 25-28, 2012.
Common misconceptions about cat scratch
disease (CSD) are that: 1) fleas or flea dirt must
be present on cats in order to transmit the bacteria
to people, 2) there is no need to test or treat
healthy cats, 3) CSD is the only Bartonella
disease, and 4) CSD is a benign self-limiting
disease. With the assistance of many of our
veterinary clients, we were able to interview
more than 500 people who had reported
developing a Bartonella disease. These
individuals had their cats tested for Bartonella at
our laboratory after they were diagnosed with a
Bartonella disease. We identified 283 people
with a Bartonella disease who were diagnosed
with the infection. 61% had developed classic
CSD with fever, lymphadenopathy, malaise, and
a papule. 23% developed CSD and sequelae
consisting of chorioretinitis, cognitive
dysfunction, psychoses, neurologic disorders,
endocarditis, and hepatosplenomegaly.
Finally,
16% developed only bartonellosis or sequelae
with no classic CSD prodrome signs. 77% of the
cases occurred in adults. 50% of the people
developed chronic myalgia and arthralgia and
30% developed mental alterations including
depression, cognitive dysfunctions, “brain fog,”
and panic disorders.
Cats that transmitted Bartonella were identified
in 201 of the 283 cases or 71%. 97% of the cats
were serologically WB positive for Bartonella
infection, 65% were healthy, 49% were kittens
under one year of age and 83% had no fleas or
flea dirt on them at the time they transmitted the
bacterium to people. The routes of infection
were identified in 69% of the cases. Of these,
75% by scratches, 13% by bites or scratches, 5%
by administering oral medication, and 31% by
unknown routes. Thus healthy kittens, less than
one year of age obtained as strays, from shelters
or as feral cats, are the most likely to transmit
Bartonella to people. The AAFP, CDC, and
many academic websites do not recommend the
testing of healthy cats for Bartonella. Excluding
the 40 veterinary professionals who had
developed Bartonella diseases in this study 94%
of the patients had NOT been informed of the
zoonotic danger of feline Bartonella by their
veterinarians before their illness occurred.
In
addition, 70% of the patients had difficulty in
obtaining a diagnosis or had to urge or insist that
their physician consider Bartonella as a possible
cause of their illness. These physicians were
unknowledgeable or were dismissive of
Bartonella diseases.
Veterinarians and physicians
must become more aware of the correct
Bartonella risks and diseases caused by feline
derived Bartonella.
Updated Bartonella Paradigm:
(The Paradigm Shift)
Cats:
1. Bartonella cause inflammatory disease in cats.
2. There are tests available for Bartonella.
3. There is therapy for Bartonella.
4. Serology can show current or past infection.
Humans:
1. Bartonella cause CSD and severe diseases.
2. CSD occurs equally in children and adults.
3. CSD is not always self-limiting- treatment may
be necessary.
4. Fleas do NOT have to be present on cats for
zoonotic transmission to occur.
5. CDC still does not recommend testing cats.
CDC Healthy Pets Healthy People
Website: www.cdc.gov/healthypets/
The CDC has redesigned this website on October
2, 2015 with information about “diseases that can
be spread from pets to people.” The director of
the One Health Office in the CDC National
Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious
Diseases said it is an excellent resource for
practitioners and their clients. In the alphabetical
list of diseases, Bartonella henselae and Cat
Scratch Disease are listed with identical
information given for both subjects. The
information is outdated and inadequate
considering there are more than 4,000 published
articles on these subjects. Incorrectly, the
website uses the term “CSD” as if it is the
etiologic agent “Bartonella.”
Although rare,
CSD can cause people to have serious
complications. CSD can affect the brain, eyes,
heart, or other internal organs.” In another
sentence concerning Bartonella in cats they state
“Bartonella henselae infection may also develop
in the mouth, urinary system, or eyes.” They
probably mean that “inflammation or disease”
may also develop. We know of no association of
Bartonella with urinary system diseases. Under
“Prevention,” there is no mention of testing cats
for Bartonella infection and therapy. Under
“Available Tests & Treatments” “People: Talk
to your doctor about testing and treatments for
CSD. CSD is typically not treated in otherwise
healthy people.” Of course CSD is only the tip of
the iceberg of Bartonella inflammatory disease in
people (see our Newsletters on
www.natvetlab.com). Under “Cats: Talk to your
veterinarian about testing and treatments for your
cat. Your veterinarian can tell you weather your cat
requires testing or treatment.” Thus, the US
national health site, the CDC, still does not give any
concrete recommendation to assist cat owners and
veterinarians to understand this dangerous zoonotic
pathogen. In addition, the site leaves the reader
with the impression that CSD is the most important
Bartonella disease which is just not true. We hope
that the CDC will quickly modify this outdated part
of their website.
**
We thank all of our clients for making
these 16 years so productive**
References:
1. Relman, DA. et al. The agent of bacillary angiomatosis:
An approach to the identification of uncultured
pathogens. N. Engl. J. Med. 323:1573, 1990.
2. Hardy, WD, Jr, Zuckerman, EE, Gold, JWM, Baron, P,
Kiehn, TE, Polsky, B, and Armstrong, D. Immunogenic
proteins of Bartonella henselae defined by western
immunoblots with naturally infected cat sera. 95th
General Meeting, American Society for Microbiology,
Washington, D.C., May 21-25, 1995.
3. VIN.com Board: Vet-to-Vet; Folders: Intn Med., Feline;
Zoonoses and Public Health. Various dates.
4. Regnery RL, Rooney JA, Johnson AM, et al.
Experimentally induced Bartonella henselae infections
followed by challenge exposure and antimicrobial therapy
in cats. Am J Vet Res 1996; 57: 1714-9. Erratum in: Am J
Vet Res. 58:803, 1997.
5. Tuzio, H., et al. Feline zoonoses guidelines from the
American Association of Feline Practitioners. . J Feline
Med Surg 7:243-274, 2005.
6. Hardy, W.D., JR., Zuckerman, E.E., Corbishley, J. et
al. Successful therapy of Bartonella henselae bacteremic
healthy pet cats. Annual Meeting, Infect. Dis. Soc. of
America, New Orleans, Sept., 1996.
7. Hardy, WD, Jr., Zuckerman, E, Corbishley, J.
Seroprevalence of Bartonella-infection in healthy and
diseased cats in the United States and Caribbean: Evidence
for Bartonella-induced diseases in cats. International
Conference of the American Society for Rickettsiology,
Big Sky, MT, August 17-22, 2001.
8. Hardy, WD, Jr., Zuckerman, EE, Corbishley, J, et al.
Efficacy of high dose, long duration Doxycycline or
Azithromycin treatment for Bartonella infections in pet
cats. Internat Conf Am Soc for Rickettsiology, 2001.
9. Hardy, WD, Jr., Zuckerman, E., & Corbishley, J.
Serological evidence that Bartonella cause gingivitis and
stomatitis in cats. American Veterinary Dental Society
Meeting, Savannah, GA, October 2002.
10. Ketring, KL, Zuckerman, EE & Hardy, WD, Jr.
Bartonella: A new etiological agent of feline ocular
diseases. JAAHA, 40: 6-12, 2004.
11. Hardy, WD, Jr., Zuckerman, E, Ketring, K, Fischer,
C, Mineo, M. Bartonella-induced ocular inflammatory
diseases of cats. Upsala J Med Sci, Suppl. 57: 37, 2005
12. Hardy, WD, Jr., and Zuckerman, EE. Human
bartonellosis: diseases caused by feline Bartonella- 84
cases. 5th Intern. Conf. on Bartonella as Emerg.
Pathogens. Pacific Grove, CA, September 2-7, 2006.
13. Hardy, WD, Jr., Zuckerman, EE, Petcher, SP and
Raclyn, P. Atypical Bartonella-Associated Diseases of
Cats and Dogs: Platelet and Pancreatic Disorders, 6
th
International Conference on Bartonella as Medical and
Veterinary Pathogens: Chester, UK, June 21-23, 2009.
14. Hardy, WD, Jr. and Zuckerman, EE. Bartonella: The
Pet Cat-Human Connection. 1st Intern One Health
Congress, Melbourne, Australia, February.14-16, 2011.
15. Pennisi, MG et al. Bartonella species infection in cats
ABCD guidelines on prevention and management. J Feline
Med Surg 15:563-569, 2013.
References can be obtained at:
www.nlm.nih.gov/ or natvetlab.com
©National Veterinary Laboratory, Inc., 2015
Special Tribute to William Hardy, Jr. VMD
Dr. Hardy is to be congratulated for his development of the Feline Bartonella Western Blot Test and his investigation into the pathology that Bartonella causes in cats and people.
Dr. Hardy's work is protecting cats from harm and enabling a serious zoonosis potential to be eliminated. There is great need for the veterinarian to work with the physician for the continued control of this very serious zoonosis. Thank you Dr. Hardy for persevering through great negativity and being steadfast in bringing valuable information to the veterinary profession and the human physician. DH DeForge, VMD 21May2016
Dr. DeForge welcomes your comments concerning his blogs. Write to: DonDeForge100@gmail.com
21May2016
Comments
Post a Comment